Compare side-by-side engineering specifications, spindle torque, RPM, axis travels, tool capacity, CNC controllers, and digital telemetry standards for Makino V22 Graphite vs DN Solutions M 5700.
|
Specification Matrix
Verified OEM & MachineSchema Data
|
Makino
View Specs Page →
|
DN Solutions
View Specs Page →
|
|---|---|---|
| 1. Machine Classification & Kinematics | ||
| Machine Type | CNC Vertical Machining Centers (VMC) | CNC Vertical Machining Centers (VMC) |
| Controlled Axes | 3-Axis Simultaneous | 3-Axis Simultaneous |
| OEM Headquarters | Japan | South Korea |
| Model Status / Year | 2024 | 2024 |
| 2. Spindle Speed & Motor Power | ||
| Maximum Spindle Speed | 40,000 RPM Highest RPM | 12,000 RPM |
| Spindle Motor Rating | 3.7 kW (5 HP) | 18.5 kW (24.8 HP) More Power |
| 3. Work Envelope & Travels (X / Y / Z) | ||
| X-Axis Travel | N/A | 1,050 mm |
| Y-Axis Travel | N/A | 570 mm |
| Z-Axis Travel | N/A | 510 mm |
| Table Surface Dimensions | Standard Worktable | Standard Worktable |
| Maximum Table Payload | Standard Capacity | Standard Capacity |
| 4. Tool Changer (ATC) & Motion Rates | ||
| Tool Magazine Capacity | 30 Tools | 30 Tools |
| Rapid Traverse Rate | High-Speed Rapid Feed | 36 m/min |
| 5. CNC Control & Telemetry Standards | ||
| Standard CNC Controller | Makino Professional 6 (Pro 6) | Fanuc 0i-Plus with iHMI |
| MTConnect Telemetry Standard | ANSI/MTC1.4 Verified | ANSI/MTC1.4 Verified |
| 6. Machine Mass & Rigidity | ||
| Net Machine Weight | 4,500 kg | 6,500 kg Heaviest Base |
When evaluating Makino V22 Graphite vs DN Solutions M 5700, shop managers must weigh spindle kinematics against overall structural rigidity. The DN Solutions M 5700 delivers a competitive edge in heavier stock removal with its 18.5 kW spindle motor. Conversely, the Makino V22 Graphite offers high-speed finishing advantages with a top speed of 40,000 RPM. Both builders adhere to standardized industrial communication protocols, facilitating MTConnect machine monitoring across digital factory floors.
When selecting between competing machining centers or turning centers, specification sheets provide only the baseline. Experienced manufacturing engineers should analyze the following core metrics:
Check whether kW and torque are rated continuously or at 15-30 minute duty cycles for roughing operations.
Heavier meehanite cast-iron machine beds absorb cutting harmonics and damp vibrations during high-feed milling.
Ensure the control system supports high-speed look-ahead (G05.1/G08) and standard MTConnect IoT monitoring.